Tag: respect

  • An open letter on the climate and nature emergency

    An open letter on the climate and nature emergency

    An open letter on the climate and nature emergency.

    645 words


    *13 November 2026 · Amanda Hariette-Scott*

    To the Prime Minister, the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, and Members of Parliament.

    ## Why you should read this

    I am a physicist, a Fellow of the Ronin Institute, and a constituent in West Yorkshire. Physics is the discipline of the part of nature that does not negotiate: energy balances, and what happens when a system is pushed past a threshold.

    I am writing because the evidence has been in front of you, from your own advisers, for years, and because the cost of being wrong lands on people with no vote and no lobbyist.

    I also expect to live a matter of months, not decades. I mention it only because it removes any motive to flatter you or to bargain with you.

    I will give you five facts and three requests. Every one of them can be checked.

    ## Five facts

    1. **The world is heading for new heat records.** The World Meteorological Organization, with the Met Office as its lead centre, reported on 28 May 2026 an 86 per cent chance that at least one year between 2026 and 2030 will be hotter than 2024, and a 75 per cent chance that the five-year mean exceeds 1.5°C above the 1850 to 1900 average. [WMO](https://wmo.int/news/media-centre/new-report-suggests-more-global-temperature-records-ahead)

    2. **Your own advisers say the plan is not there.** The Climate Change Committee’s report to Parliament, laid on 24 June 2026, finds credible plans for 44 per cent of the emissions cuts needed to meet the UK’s 2030 target. A further 17 per cent is not covered by the Government’s pathway at all. [CCC](https://www.theccc.org.uk/publication/progress-in-reducing-emissions-2026-report-to-parliament/)

    3. **The recent fall in emissions is not a trend you can bank.** UK emissions fell by 7.7 MtCO2e (1.8 per cent) in 2024. Electricity supply fell by 7.4 Mt and industry by 3.6 Mt, the latter mainly because the Port Talbot steelworks closed temporarily. [CCC](https://www.theccc.org.uk/publication/progress-in-reducing-emissions-2026-report-to-parliament/)

    4. **The licensing ban has a side door.** The Energy Independence Bill factsheet, published on 4 November 2026, ends new North Sea licences but creates Transitional Energy Certificates that “enable some additional oil and gas production in areas bordering or in close proximity to already licensed fields”. It sets no limit on volume. [DESNZ](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/energy-independence-bill-factsheets/ending-new-oil-and-gas-licences-and-introducing-transitional-energy-certificates)

    5. **The law that would bind all of this has never had a vote on its merits.** The Climate and Nature Bill would put targets for emissions and nature into law and create a Climate and Nature Assembly. Zero Hour counts 192 MPs in support, 89 of them Labour. It reached second reading in January 2025 and the debate was adjourned. [Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_and_Nature_Bill), [Zero Hour](https://www.zerohour.uk/bill)

    On 12 November, at COP31, the Prime Minister told world leaders: “the reality is now the world will reach 1.5 degrees.” (PM speech at COP31 climate summit, gov.uk, 12 November 2026.) If that is the Government’s own position, the three requests below are the minimum that follows from it.

    ## Three requests

    Each is within the gift of the people I am addressing.

    1. **Close the side door.** The Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero should amend the Energy Independence Bill, before it completes its Commons stages, to put a numerical cap and an end date on what Transitional Energy Certificates may permit.

    2. **Show the arithmetic.** The Prime Minister should publish by 31 March 2027 a costed, dated plan for the more than half of the 2030 reductions that lacks credible plans, starting with the electrification measures the Climate Change Committee recommends.

    3. **Let Parliament vote.** The Prime Minister and the Leader of the House should adopt the Climate and Nature Bill as a Government Bill, or give it Government time in this session, so that Members vote on its merits.

    ## Reply

    I ask for a written reply by 11 December 2026 that answers each request by number. If you dispute a fact above, tell me which one and why, with a source, and I will correct it publicly.

    I will publish your reply, or the absence of one.

    Mx. Amanda Hariette-Scott
    Physicist, CEO, and Fellow of the Ronin Institute.

    Reply to: amanda.h.scott@gmail.com

  • No magic conjures; no void finds

    No magic conjures; no void finds

    No Magic Conjures, No Void Finds


    2,553 words


    A ballad in twelve cantos:

    By Amanda Hariette-Scott.

    Published by (c) 2026 Cydonis Media, a wholly owned subsiduary of Cydonis Heavy Industries, (C.H.I), Ltd.

    (https://cydonis.co.uk/about)

    Prologue: The Refusal of the Muse

    I will not call upon a muse,
    nor beg a god for flame;
    I’ll ask the ledger and the light
    and every honest name.

    This is a song about a debt:
    that all things have a source,
    that nothing climbs out of the dark
    without a cause or force;

    and of its twin, the harder claim:
    that emptiness is blind:
    no void will ever find the lost;
    somebody has to find.

    So here’s a ballad, plainly made
    for one who checked my sums:
    of physics, grief, and lies that run,
    and how the true thing comes.

    Come, bring a lamp, and leave the spells,
    a pencil, not a wand;
    the dark is only light withheld,
    and light is close at hand.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    I. The Ledger

    A brewer’s son in Salford hung
    a weight above a vat;
    it fell, it turned a paddle wheel,
    and warmth came out of that.

    The warming was a sliver’s width
    on glass of finest grade,
    but what the falling weight had lost
    the water had repaid.

    So heat is work, and work is heat,
    and neither comes for free;
    the sum is kept through every change
    by stern economy.

    Yet dreamers drew their endless wheels
    and sold them by the score,
    till Paris wearied of the lot
    and shut the learned door.

    Then Emmy Noether, unpaid, barred
    from the lecturer’s chair,
    took Hilbert’s puzzle, turned it round,
    and found the reason there:

    She proved that every symmetry
    the laws of nature hold
    secures a number that remains
    however things unfold.

    The same tomorrow as today?
    Then energy holds true.
    The same in Kent as Samarkand?
    Then momentum holds, too.

    The Reich dismissed her, thirty-three;
    she crossed the ocean wide.
    No statute can repeal a proof.
    The theorem has not died.

    So when a salesman, smooth with charm,
    proves motors need no fuel,
    ask only: whence the energy?
    The books are strict, not cruel.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    II. The Null and the Seething

    In eighteen eighty-seven, two
    men set a mirrored stone
    to swim in pools of quicksilver
    and catch the wind unknown.

    They turned the stone and watched the light
    for any shift or sway,
    and found no difference at all
    by night, by noon, by day.

    No aether found: a null result;
    yet nothing, honestly seen,
    undid the furniture of space
    and let the new thing in.

    But emptiness is not the blank
    the ancients thought they saw;
    the vacuum trembles with the fields
    that underwrite the law.

    Two golden plates, set close, are pressed
    by that unquiet sea,
    and Casimir’s small, honest push
    is there for all to see.

    And those who sell you zero-point
    to run the house for free
    forget that ground is ground: the floor
    of all that there can be.

    You cannot drain the lowest state:
    there’s nowhere lower still.
    The hum is real, and mapped, and true;
    it will not turn your mill.

    So hold both truths: the void is rich,
    and none of it is spare;
    the wonder and the warning grow
    from the same root, laid bare.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    III. The Pigeons and the Pulse

    At Holmdel in New Jersey, two
    men with a giant horn
    heard hiss from every part of sky
    by midnight and by morn.

    They scraped the pigeons’ leavings out,
    they checked each rivet’s seam,
    and only when the humble failed
    did they allow the dream.

    It was the oldest light there is,
    set loose when atoms formed,
    and stretched through fourteen billion years
    until it barely warmed.

    At Cambridge, sixty-seven, Bell,
    a student, saw a trace
    upon a mile of paper chart
    that ticked with metred grace.

    They joked of Little Green Men, but
    they would not shout it loud;
    they sought for more, and found a flock:
    no beacons from a crowd.

    They were the ash of burnt-out suns,
    collapsed, and spun, and lit,
    a lighthouse swept across the dark
    with no one tending it.

    And is the world the lesser thing
    for having been explained?
    The dead star turning in its night
    outshines what we had feigned.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    IV. The Long Library

    Eratosthenes took a stick,
    a well, a camel’s pace,
    and from the angle of a shadow
    he measured Earth’s round face.

    He came astonishingly close
    with sun, and step, and stone;
    two thousand years before a probe
    could check what he had shown.

    The scholars of the ages after
    knew well the Earth was round;
    the myth that they believed it flat
    is, in itself, unsound.

    We tell of one great fire that took
    Alexandria’s shelves,
    but loss is mostly slow neglect,
    a thing we do ourselves.

    In Cairo, near the year one thousand,
    Ibn al-Haytham sealed a room,
    and through one hole the world came in,
    inverted, through the gloom.

    He wrote: the seeker should not trust
    the sages, nor his own
    first thought; but doubt, and test, and weigh,
    and let the proof be known.

    And hardest is the final clause:
    to doubt the thing you hold
    most dear, the theory of your youth,
    and test it, and be told.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    V. The Swifter Wing

    A lie takes wing; the truth, on foot,
    comes limping from behind;
    so Swift observed, though now the line
    is Twain’s, in many a mind.

    Which proves the point, and proves it twice:
    the wrong name flew, and caught;
    the checking takes an afternoon,
    the sharing, not a thought.

    In Vienna, eighteen forty-seven,
    Semmelweis made it clear:
    the hands that came from corpse to bed
    had brought the fever near.

    He had them wash in chlorine, and
    the deaths fell, week on week;
    but pride is stung by being proved
    a hazard to the weak.

    Dismissed, he raged, was locked away,
    and died in ‘sixty-five
    of sepsis from a wound: the foe
    he’d taught us to survive.

    The truth was patient, being true:
    Pasteur, then Lister, came,
    and every surgeon scrubs today
    and half-recalls his name.

    And Piltdown Man, so proudly ours,
    a jaw, a skull, a lie,
    stood forty years upon the shelf
    till fluorine told us why.

    A wish is half the forger’s work:
    the rest is done by those
    who hear the thing they hoped to hear
    and never ask who knows.

    Now every pocket holds a press
    that never sleeps or tires,
    and feeds on anger, haste, and fear,
    and fans them into fires.

    The cost is never abstract: fear
    dressed as a study; then
    the children who’d have been quite safe
    are in the wards again.

    There is no spell to stop a lie
    that’s learned to wear a coat;
    the cure is slower: show your work,
    and mark each thing you wrote.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    VI. The Hollow Atom

    At Manchester, a student fired
    bright alphas at thin gold;
    most sailed straight through, as theory said,
    but a few came back, we’re told.

    The chief declared it quite as strange
    as if a naval shell
    had bounced from tissue paper, and
    come hurtling back pell-mell.

    So every atom is a pea
    in the middle of a town;
    how then can any table hold
    a cup, and not fall down?

    It holds, because the fields push back,
    and fermions will not share
    one state; the emptiness is law,
    and law is what is there.

    And Cavendish, in ‘ninety-eight,
    a shy man in a shed,
    hung lead on lead from slender wire
    and weighed the world instead.

    We have been wrong: phlogiston, aether,
    caloric, and the rest;
    and every error, when it fell,
    was felled by a finer test.

    That is no weakness. It’s the point:
    a craft that hunts the flaw,
    and having found it, says so, loud,
    and writes anew the law.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    VII. Nature Cannot Be Briefed

    In January, ‘eighty-six,
    the engineers had warned
    that seals would stiffen in the cold;
    Challenger flew. We mourned.

    Then Feynman, with a clamp, a glass
    of water full of ice,
    made rubber lose its spring
    before them in a trice.

    His note was plain, and has not aged:
    the facts must lead, not trail;
    for nature cannot be deceived
    and spin will always fail.

    That April, by Pripyat, a core
    carried a flaw, unnamed:
    its boiling coolant, turned to void,
    fed what it should have tamed.

    A near-miss, years before, was filed
    and stamped, and locked away;
    the men who met it were not told
    what any page could say.

    The state kept silent. But the wind
    bore ash across the sea,
    and gauges rang in Sweden, and
    the truth, at last, was free.

    A lie is a loan the future signs;
    and truth will call it in,
    with interest, and a patient hand;
    and nature, too, will win.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    VIII. The Empty Chair

    Houdini, when his mother died,
    the man no chain could hold,
    went sitting with the mediums
    for comfort, as of old.

    He wanted it to be real. He knew
    each trick, for they were his;
    and still the grieving child in him
    held out for one that is.

    He found the cracking toe-joints, and
    the trumpets on their strings,
    the cheesecloth of the ectoplasm,
    and all such sorry things.

    His friend, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle,
    had lost a son to flu,
    and wanted so to find him that
    he thought the fairies true.

    He left a pact with Bess, a code
    which, if the dead could write,
    he’d send. Ten Halloweens she kept,
    then snuffed the candle-light.

    I know that wish. I have it still:
    a kitchen, late, and bare,
    the kettle’s click, a chair pulled out,
    and no one sitting there.

    I will not hire a stranger’s mouth
    to say the things you’d say;
    you’d see the trick inside a minute,
    and laugh it all away.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    IX. What the Ledger Keeps

    What does the ledger keep of you?
    I will not lie to me:
    no voice, no warmth, no thought that thinks,
    no pattern left to see.

    The atoms that you wore were forged
    in stars that died before
    the Sun was lit; and now they pass
    to leaf, and wind, and shore.

    And light that left your face one day
    in summer, in the park,
    is out among the nearer stars,
    still travelling through the dark.

    No void can find what once has been
    and take it from the page:
    the fact that you were here is fixed
    for every coming age.

    That is no comfort, and no claim
    that you are lingering near;
    it is a fact, and facts are things
    I can lean on, down here.

    The law that breaks the cup, and will
    not mend its shards again,
    is why I have a past to hold,
    and why I hold the pain.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    X. The Plain-Lit Halls

    There is a kind of peace that’s built
    by looking, not away;
    you set down what was done, and who,
    in the plain light of day.

    The other peace is cheap: a hush,
    a rug on a rotten floor;
    it holds until the first hard rain
    and fails as it did before.

    In South Africa, in plain-lit halls,
    a nation heard its past:
    the guilty speaking, plainly, to
    the families, at last.

    It was not perfect: some went free
    that justice might have caught,
    and some who spoke got nothing back;
    but still, the truth was sought.

    In Argentina, students learned
    to read a buried bone,
    and dug where thousands had been vanished
    and brought their names back home.

    In Ireland, too, the vanished lay
    in bog, and field, and shore;
    the void gives no one back. It took
    a spade, and years, and more.

    You cannot forgive what you’ve not seen,
    nor mourn what is not named;
    and peace is not forgetting, but
    remembering, unashamed.

    And in the smaller wars at home,
    where brothers, sisters part,
    the same arithmetic applies:
    say what happened; then start.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    XI. The Charge

    Ask first what would change your mind;
    if nothing could, beware;
    a claim that no result can touch
    is not a claim, but air.

    Ask next: what pays for it? What turns
    the wheel? Where does it start?
    A tale with nothing under it
    is either ghost, or art.

    Ask third: who tried to break it? How?
    How hard, and with what skill?
    Be wary of the praised, untested:
    let doubters have their fill.

    But keep your edge for what is claimed,
    and kindness for the claimer;
    most people passing on a lie
    are frightened, not its framer.

    Contempt has never changed a mind;
    it only bars the door;
    a bridge is made of patience, and
    one fact, and then one more.

    And you can be fooled. The cleverest
    are not exempt: the more
    a mind can reason, the better it can
    defend what it chose before.

    So when you’re wrong, and you will be,
    say so, and say it plain;
    each change of mind, made openly,
    makes truth less hard to gain.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    XII. The Budget of the Sun

    The Sun is not a gift. It spends
    four million tonnes a second,
    and all that lives is living off
    the budget it has reckoned.

    And life is order, bought with heat
    sent outward to the dark:
    a leaf, a cell, a mind, a home,
    a small and local spark.

    And love is order too: two lives
    held steady, year by year,
    and paid for in the plainest coin:
    attention, and being here.

    No spell could give me what I had;
    it was not conjured, but made
    by every day of ordinary work,
    and so is not mislaid.

    Some day, long past all human count,
    the last star will be spent;
    till then the Sun is lent to us,
    and we to each other, lent.

    No magic conjures, no void finds.

    Envoi

    So this is what I have to give,
    and all I’d ask of you:
    that nothing’s made of nothing, and
    that what is true is true;

    that wishing never turned a wheel
    or called a wave to shore;
    that someone must go out and look,
    and look, and look some more;

    that what is false can be unpicked
    with patience, and with care;
    that what is true was always so,
    and waits, and will be there;

    that those we love, though gone, are not
    unmade, and not undone:
    the fact of them is in the world
    as firm as any sun;

    that those who err are not our foes
    but kin; that they, too, grieve;
    that many a lie is only fear,
    and fear can be relieved.

    For everything that is was made
    of something, long ago;
    and what is lost is lost somewhere,
    and we are those who go

    to look, with lamp and pencil, and
    with doubt, and open hands.
    No magic conjures. No void finds.
    The rest is ours. It stands.

    Whispered on the wind…

    * “Cydonis…”!” *

  • Eleven hours styx (in Tartarus).

    Eleven hours styx (in Tartarus).

    The other day I crawled from my living room to my bathroom to answer a call of nature. I remember washing my hands on my knees afterwards – that was the moment I understood something had gone seriously wrong. My body, already worn down by a Long COVID flare that has followed me since 2022, had stopped being negotiable with me. I crawled back to the living room and called an ambulance.


    I recognised, with a strange kind of clarity, that I was in danger.
    The ambulance took about fifty minutes to arrive. I lay on the floor and picked up a magazine article about soy sauce – something small and ordinary to hold onto while everything else felt enormous. I thought about what might happen if I passed out before help came: that paramedics might have to break my door down to reach me. I pictured it more than once. I accepted it as a possible outcome. That’s an odd kind of peace to make, alone on a floor, but I made it.


    When the ambulance arrived, I made it to the door myself, with great difficulty. Opening it brought an enormous wave of relief – followed almost immediately by trepidation, when the crew mentioned how busy the hospital was that day.
    In the ambulance, flat on my back, I felt every bump in the road land directly in my joints. And somewhere in the middle of that pain, the EMT and I ended up singing “Mad World” together. Neither of us quite started it – we both did, at the same time. It remains one of the strangest and most human moments of the whole ordeal: two strangers, meeting in a song, while one of them was in genuine crisis.


    At the hospital, a nurse commented on my Star Trek: The Next Generation t-shirt on the way in. Small kindness, register kept intact.


    Then the wait began. Eleven hours, from ambulance arrival to actually seeing a doctor. A waiting room that was extremely hot and extremely busy, with chairs that seemed engineered to be as uncomfortable as possible for people who were, definitionally, all unwell. I tried desperately to reach my sleeping sister by phone. Not being able to get through to her was, honestly, existentially horrific – a specific kind of alone that goes beyond simply being alone in a room. It’s being unreachable to the one person who could reach you.


    She saw my voicemail notifications about an hour after I arrived. When she got to the hospital, it felt like being rescued by Supergirl.
    At one point in the waiting room, an Irish man who was clearly in the grip of a severe mental health crisis – fixated on death, with an intense, thousand-yard stare – began harassing my sister and me. It went on until hospital security and nursing staff stepped in to manage the situation. It was frightening in the moment, but it also underlined something about that waiting room: everyone in it, in one way or another, was in crisis, and the system meant to hold all of us at once was stretched far too thin to do it well.


    Somewhere in that waiting room, gallows humour crept in – nurses talking about The Last of Us and The Pitt, a show literally about an overwhelmed emergency department, while living through a version of it themselves. It wasn’t despair. It was people staying human inside something exhausting, the way healthcare workers often do.
    I don’t have a tidy conclusion to offer. What I have is what happened, told in order: the crawl, the calculated call for help, the fifty minutes with a soy sauce article, the song in the ambulance, the small kindness about a t-shirt, the hour of silence, and then not being alone anymore.


    That’s the account, for whoever needs it, including future me.
    – written the day after, for the record.


  • The Missing Specification (For Humanity) And The Great Polycrisis Filter.

    The Missing Specification (For Humanity) And The Great Polycrisis Filter.

    Why moral bio-cybernetic/bioenhancement fails at the design document, not the ethics committee.

    admin avatar
    2,290 words


    Proposals to biologically engineer human moral dispositions – to make people more compassionate, more cooperative, less prone to defection – are usually met with ethical objections. Consent. Autonomy. Authenticity. Value lock-in. The long shadow of eugenics.

    These objections are serious and several of them are quite decisive. But they are also, in a particular sense, premature. They engage the proposal as though the technical programme were ready and the only remaining question were whether we ought to run it. That framing flatters the proposal. It grants it a maturity it does not have.

    There is a more revealing test, and it is the one engineers use on any large proposal before arguing about whether to fund it: **try to write the specification.**

    Not a manifesto. Not a research agenda. A design document – the artefact that lets someone else build the thing, and lets a third party check whether it worked. Every field filled in, every acceptance criterion stated, every assumption made explicit enough to be falsified.

    When you actually attempt this for moral bioenhancement, something instructive happens. The document does not turn out to be *controversial*. It turns out to be **blank**. And the pattern of which fields are blank is more informative than any of the ethical arguments.

    —

    The construct problem: you are not turning up a dial

    The first field in any specification is: *what, precisely, is being modified?*

    “Compassion” is a folk-psychological term. It is not a variable. Before you can build anything you must commit to a decomposition – typically something like an affective component (felt concern at another’s distress), a motivational component (disposition to act at personal cost), a cognitive component (accuracy of your model of the other’s state), a behavioural output (rate and magnitude of costly prosocial acts), and – critically – a **scope function**: to whom does it extend, and how does it decay with social distance?

    That last component is where naive versions of the project die.

    Human prosociality is not a scalar quantity with a gain knob attached. It is a gradient over social distance: steep and high near kin and in-group, falling off quickly with distance, and effectively flat at the level of statistical strangers. This is why we are simultaneously the species that will run into a burning building for a neighbour and the species that can read a famine death toll over breakfast.

    Which means the thing that would actually change outcomes at civilisational scale is not the *amplitude* of caring. It is the **shape of the discount function**. You do not want a higher curve. You want a flatter one.

    Nobody has a genetic or neural handle on the shape. And the best-known intervention that raises amplitude appears to make the shape *worse*. Oxytocin spent about a decade as the “moral molecule” before the picture complicated: alongside well-known affiliative effects, a body of work found it strengthening in-group bonding while in some paradigms increasing out-group hostility or defensive aggression. The replication record across this literature is mixed enough that no single result should be leaned on hard. But the direction of the concern is the point. Raising the gain on a parochial system plausibly yields more effective parochialism – more devoted tribalists, better at their tribalism.

    There is a second constraint that most versions of the proposal omit entirely: **stability under exploitation**. Any modified disposition must be viable in a mixed population that still contains unmodified defectors. A disposition toward unconditional cooperation is not a stable strategy; it is removed from the population – economically, socially, reproductively – by the people who lack it. Making people kinder inside an unchanged incentive landscape does not produce a kinder world. It produces exploitable people.

    So the real target is not “more compassion.” It is something closer to *conditional cooperation, with an unbiased scope function, and with defection-detection and sanctioning capacity fully intact.* That is a much stranger object than the one people imagine. It is also, notably, much closer to what humans already have than to what the proposal would install.

    **Status of this field: unresolved – and not primarily as an empirical matter.** It is a conceptual problem that must be settled before measurement is even meaningful.

    —

    The measurement gate

    This is the field that stops the programme, and it stops it completely.

    Any intervention specification requires a primary endpoint: a measure with construct validity (it measures the target, not social desirability), test–retest reliability sufficient to detect your expected effect size, sensitivity to within-individual change over the intervention window, resistance to demand characteristics (subjects must not be able to score well by inferring what you want), and ecological validity (it must predict field behaviour, not merely laboratory behaviour).

    What actually exists falls into three families, and all three have known, documented problems:

    – **Self-report instruments.** Transparently gameable. Correlate substantially with how respondents wish to be seen.
    – **Economic games** (dictator, ultimatum, public goods, trust). Behaviour in these correlates weakly-to-modestly with real-world prosocial behaviour. The lab-to-field transfer problem here is one of the more uncomfortable open sores in the literature.
    – **Confederate-based laboratory paradigms.** Better ecological validity, but poor scalability and severe single-use problems – you cannot re-run them on the same subject.

    The psychometric reliability of these instruments is nowhere near what would be required to detect the modest effect sizes any realistic intervention would produce.

    The comparison that makes this vivid: a cardiovascular intervention has LDL cholesterol as a validated surrogate endpoint, blood pressure as a second, and hard endpoints – infarction, mortality – ascertained at registry scale with near-perfect reliability.

    **There is no LDL of compassion. There is no mortality-equivalent hard endpoint.** There is nothing you could enter in the “primary outcome measure” field of a trial registration that a competent reviewer would not reject.

    This is not a difficulty. It is a category failure. Without a validated endpoint there is no dose-finding, no efficacy claim, no safety signal, and no way to distinguish a working intervention from a broken one. You would be optimising against a function you cannot evaluate.

    —

    The causal chain has no established arrows

    A specification requires a causal model with every link established and quantified:

    `intervention → molecular change → circuit change → systems-level change → psychological change → behavioural change`

    What exists is a correlational sketch of one link. The empathy/compassion dissociation work – Singer, Klimecki and colleagues – implicates anterior insula and anterior cingulate cortex in empathic distress, and medial orbitofrontal cortex, ventral striatum and affiliation-associated regions in compassion. This is genuinely interesting, and the finding that compassion training increases positive affect while empathy training increases distress and burnout is one of the more useful results in the area.

    But it should be read as suggestive, not as a wiring diagram. It is correlational. It is spatially coarse – a functional imaging voxel contains on the order of a million neurons. Sample sizes are typically small, and this subfield has documented reproducibility problems for precisely this class of finding.

    What is missing is any **causal** manipulation that reliably, durably, and selectively increases the construct. Oxytocin was the strongest candidate and its literature partially collapsed under replication pressure; even the question of whether intranasal administration achieves meaningful central nervous system delivery remains contested. Contemplative training produces real effects, but modest ones, requiring ongoing practice – a behavioural intervention, not a lever a biological one could be built on.

    —

    Genetic architecture: no editable targets

    For any germline proposal, the specification requires target loci with established causal effect, characterised effect sizes, a complete pleiotropy map, and characterised epistasis and gene–environment interaction.

    For prosociality-adjacent traits – agreeableness, self-reported empathy – SNP-based heritability is modest and polygenic scores explain a low single-digit percentage of variance in independent samples. (Treat specific figures as approximate and check current sources; the direction is not in doubt.) The architecture is massively polygenic – thousands of variants of individually negligible effect – heavily pleiotropic, and poorly transferable across ancestries and environments.

    Then there is a recursion problem that is rarely acknowledged: **a genome-wide association study is only as good as its phenotype.** Run against the invalid instruments described above, what you recover is the genetic architecture of *scoring highly on a questionnaire*. That is not the target. It may not even be adjacent to the target.

    Multiplex editing at the scale of thousands of loci, with uncharacterised epistasis and an unmapped pleiotropy burden, is not a hard engineering problem awaiting effort. It sits outside the space of things currently attemptable.

    —

    The safety instrument is inside the system it monitors

    This is the field I find genuinely novel, and it has no analogue in ordinary medicine.

    Post-market drug safety rests on adverse event reporting. Patients notice something has gone wrong and report it. The system assumes the patient’s evaluative faculty is intact and independent of the intervention.

    For a values-modifying intervention, that assumption fails by construction. The adverse event class *includes changes to the faculty that generates the report*. If the intervention shifts what a person values, then self-report is compromised as a safety instrument in exactly the failure mode you most need to detect. A population successfully modified toward a particular specification of compassion may no longer contain anyone disposed to recognise the modification as a harm.

    You would therefore need an external, non-self-report harm criterion, specified in advance, held by someone outside the modified population. Nobody has (yet…) proposed a workable one.

    Note that this is not a philosophical objection dressed up as an engineering one. It is a missing section in the safety file. And it generalises: irreversibility is not merely one cost to be weighed against others, because it removes the mechanism by which anything gets weighed later. Ordinary bad policy is reversed because those harmed by it object. This is the one class of intervention that can eliminate the constituency capable of identifying the error.

    —

    What the blanks tell us:

    Lay the fields out and the completion state is stark. Delivery technology has partial content and active research behind it. Nearly everything else is empty – and the two most upstream fields, construct definition and outcome measurement, are empty in ways that no amount of funding or intelligence resolves from a single location. They are filled by cohorts, instruments, longitudinal data, and decades.

    Two things follow.

    **First: the ethical objections and the technical emptiness point the same way.** This is worth noticing rather than treating as coincidence. The consent problem, the value lock-in problem, and the pharmacovigilance problem are the same structural fact appearing in three registers – an intervention that alters the evaluator cannot be evaluated by the altered. That the technical specification is blank at precisely the points where the ethics is most troubling is not an accident. It reflects that we do not understand the object well enough to specify it *or* to consent to it.

    **Second: the causal premise is probably wrong anyway.** The proposal assumes that destructive collective behaviour is primarily a psychological trait being expressed. But humans are already extraordinarily cooperative by primate standards – we punish unfairness at cost to ourselves, we cooperate with strangers we will never meet again. What competitive systems do is *select* for defection at the level of firms and institutions, largely independent of the dispositions of the people inside them.

    The evidence for this is not subtle. When emergency conditions suspend normal procurement controls – competitive tender, due diligence, published contracts, audit trails – fraud losses jump by orders of magnitude. Same population, same dispositions, different controls. Removing the checking is what changes the behaviour.

    None of which means dispositions are irrelevant. Some people are cruel, some enjoy it, and the variance is real. But what institutions and norms determine is how much *scope* those dispositions get – whether cruelty is costly or licensed, marginal or ambient. Both halves are true, and the tractable half is the second one. Ostrom’s work on commons governance showed groups solving defection problems through monitoring, graduated sanctions, and local rule-making, with nobody’s psyche altered at all.

    And where genuinely catastrophic risk is the concern, it concentrates in a very small number of people with access to weapons systems, engineered pathogens, or critical infrastructure. Screening and constraining that population is orders of magnitude more tractable than modifying a species. It has real problems – who screens the screeners, capture risk – but they are the ordinary problems of institutional design rather than the irreversible rewriting of a lineage.

    —

    Where the real problem is

    If you take the specification exercise seriously, the interesting frontier turns out not to be where the proposal points.

    The measurement field is a live, unsolved, genuinely deep problem: how to construct a valid and reliable instrument for a latent construct that resists direct observation, where the act of measurement perturbs the thing measured and the subject has incentive to game the readout.

    That is a problem in **measurement theory** more than in biology. Psychology has been notably bad at it – partly because the field’s training does not emphasise what a physicist’s or metrologist’s does: error propagation, calibration, sensitivity limits, distinguishing signal from instrument artefact, and knowing when your resolution cannot support your claim.

    Solving it would be valuable regardless of what anyone concluded about enhancement. It is upstream of clinical trials in psychiatry, of policy evaluation, of most of behavioural science. It is where someone with quantitative training would have a genuine edge.

    The specification exercise is not, in the end, an argument for despair about the underlying goal. It is a redirection. The document is blank at the top, and the top is where the work is.

    So let that work begin.




    *Further reading and citations: Persson & Savulescu, ***Unfit for the Future*** (the strongest case for the affirmative); John Harris’s reply on the freedom to fall; Paul Bloom, ***Against Empathy***; Elinor Ostrom, ***Governing the Commons***; Singer & Klimecki on the empathy/compassion dissociation; Habermas, ***The Future of Human Nature***.*

  • A Secular Humanist’s Take on Trump’s Mt. Rushmore Sermon

    A Secular Humanist’s Take on Trump’s Mt. Rushmore Sermon


    The Menace That Wasn’t: A Secular Humanist, Green Party Take on Trump’s Rushmore Sermon

    7–11 minutes
    1,669 words
    admin avatar


    There’s a particular genre of American political theatre that never quite goes out of style: the mountain, the flag, the borrowed marble faces of dead presidents, and a man at a podium warning you that the enemy is already inside the gates. On July 3, 2026, on the eve of the country’s 250th birthday, Donald Trump stood in front of Mount Rushmore and reached for the oldest prop in that theatre’s closet – communism – and dusted it off for an audience that, statistically, has never lived under it, never studied it seriously, and would be hard-pressed to name a single line from the *Communist Manifesto*. That’s not an accident. The speech wasn’t really about communism. It was about who gets to define “American,” who gets cast as a threat to it, and who gets to stand at the centre of the frame while doing the casting.

    I’m writing this as a secular humanist and a GPEW & UK Green Party Member – which means I come to this with two specific moral and political objections. One is to political rhetoric that fuses patriotism to a particular ‘god'(s), and treats disbelief, doubt, or a different faith as a moral defect. The other is to language that smears environmental and economic reform as a totalitarian plot, because that language has spent forty years being used against exactly the kind of politics I care about.

    The Return of an Old Formula

    Red-baiting has a rhythm to it, and Trump’s speech followed the rhythm precisely: name an external ideology, claim it has infiltrated the homeland through newcomers, strip it of any economic or historical specificity, and then attach to it every imaginable evil – theft, godlessness, lawlessness, murder – until “communism” stops meaning an actual set of economic ideas and starts meaning simply *the enemy*. It is the McCarthy playbook with better production values. The tell is in the vagueness. Nowhere in the speech is there an actual communist policy platform, an actual party programme, an actual piece of legislation. There’s only atmosphere: menace, resurgence, mass control. That vagueness isn’t a flaw in the rhetoric – it’s the whole function of it. A vague enemy can absorb almost anyone the speaker wants it to: a socialist mayor, an immigrant, a public school teacher, a climate scientist, a union organiser, a Green.

    And that absorption is precisely why this matters to those of us who spend our political lives arguing for climate policy, wealth redistribution, and structural reform of capitalism. We have watched this same conflation trick used against basic proposals – public healthcare, a carbon tax, tenant protections – for decades. “Socialism” and “communism” get used almost interchangeably in speeches like this one, which is either ignorance of or indifference to the fact that Scandinavian social democracy, American-style progressive taxation, eco-socialism, and Soviet-style single-party state ownership are not the same thing, do not share a history, and do not share an outcome. Collapsing them into one bogeyman isn’t an argument. It’s a way of making argument unnecessary.

    “They Don’t Love ‘God(s)’…” – The Theological Loyalty Test

    The line that should trouble anyone who takes secularism seriously is the claim that the supposed communist newcomers “don’t love God,” “don’t want God,” and have no interest in religion – as though these were self-evidently disqualifying traits in an American, and as though love of ‘God(s)’, (fantasies and delusions) were a reliable predictor of respect for the rule of law. This is not a description of communism. Historical communist states were genuinely, often violently, hostile to organised religion, and that history is real and worth reckoning with. But the rhetorical move here isn’t a critique of state atheism as state policy – it’s an implication that irreligion itself, present-tense, in an ordinary citizen or newcomer, is evidence of moral rot.

    That should unsettle a lot more people than it seems to. Non-religious Americans are one of the fastest-growing demographic categories in the country. Only a portion of them are politically left of centre, and essentially none of them are Soviet apparatchiks. To imply that lack of religious devotion correlates with lawlessness and “mass murder” isn’t a factual claim about political ideology – it’s a loyalty test with a cross on it, dressed up as a warning about Marx. A secular humanist ethic doesn’t need ‘God'(s )to generate a respect for law, human dignity, or “your God-given rights,” to use the speech’s own phrase; it grounds those things in the observable, arguable, revisable project of human reason and empathy instead. A speech that treats a categorical love of God as the load-bearing wall of civic virtue is not just historically sloppy about communism – it is quietly, casually exclusionary towards tens of millions of its own citizens.

    Who Gets to Be a “Newcomer”

    The line linking the “communist menace” explicitly to “newcomers to our country” deserves its own paragraph, because it is doing quiet, ugly work. Immigration anxiety and communism panic have been braided together in American rhetoric since at least the first Red Scare of 1919-20, when Attorney General Palmer’s raids targeted immigrant labour organisers as much as they targeted any coherent Bolshevik threat. The pattern repeats here: an ideological menace is described, and then it is given a face, and the face belongs to the person who arrived more recently than the speaker’s own ancestors did. It’s worth noting, as an aside that the speech itself doesn’t, that nearly every American is descended from a newcomer at some point, and that the timeline of “how long ago you got here” has never been a meaningful predictor of political ideology.

    The Irony of “Mass Control”

    Here’s where the Green in me can’t help but notice the mirror. The speech describes communism as “an ideology of mass theft, mass control, mass lies, and mass murder” – and follows it, in the same set of remarks, with a call to eliminate the Senate filibuster and pass a specific piece of legislation so that a single party need “not lose an election for 100 years.” Whatever one thinks of the filibuster as a procedural tool, a call for a hundred years of uncontested one-party rule, delivered in the same breath as a warning about “mass control,” is not a minor rhetorical stumble. It’s the thing the speech claims to be warning against, worn as a lapel pin.

    This is the pattern that Greens and civil libertarians alike should recognise regardless of who is doing it: concentrated, unaccountable power is the actual danger, whether it wears a hammer-and-sickle or a flag pin. A one-party state is a one-party state whether its founding myth is proletarian revolution or American exceptionalism. The environmental movement in particular has learned this lesson the hard way – ecological collapse has been accelerated as readily by unaccountable state bureaucracies (the Soviet Union’s environmental record is genuinely catastrophic, from the Aral Sea to Chernobyl) as by unaccountable corporate power in market democracies. The threat was never the label. It was the absence of checks.

    Stolen Land, Real History

    The speech also takes a swing at people “who tell our children that we live on stolen land or that our heroes were oppressors,” framing this as a communist lie about heritage. This is worth pausing on simply because it’s checkable. The displacement of Native nations from their land through treaty violation, forced removal, and military conquest is not a Marxist interpretation of American history; it’s the documented factual record, taught in university history departments with no particular ideological bent and available in the treaties themselves. Refusing to look at that record doesn’t make the country’s founding more secure – it just makes the founding myth more brittle, because myths that can’t survive contact with evidence eventually break all at once instead of bending gradually. A humanist approach to history says the honest version, oppressors and all, produces a more resilient civic identity than an insistence on unblemished virtue. You cannot build a durable patriotism on a historical record you’re not allowed to examine.

    None of this is to say communism as historically practised is above criticism – quite the opposite. The gulag system, the Holodomor, the Cultural Revolution, and the killing fields are real, and their death tolls are not political footballs; they are among the worst human-caused catastrophes on record and deserve unflinching moral reckoning, not what-about-ism from the left and not cartoonish flattening from the right. But precisely because that history is so serious, it deserves to be invoked accurately – as an argument about the specific dangers of one-party rule, command economies, and the suppression of dissent – rather than as a floating epithet applied to socialists, environmentalists, secularists, and immigrants alike because they are politically inconvenient this news cycle.

    A Green politics that argues for public transit, a carbon price, universal healthcare, and stronger labour protections is not a request for a politburo. It is, if anything, a bet that democratic institutions – the same institutions this speech claims to be defending – are strong enough to legislate ambitious change without collapsing into the very authoritarianism the speech warns against. Painting that politics with the same brush as Stalinism isn’t vigilance. It’s an [ironically] bad faith way of making sure ambitious reform never gets argued on its merits at all.

    The Actual Choice

    The speech ends on a binary: you can be a communist, or you can be a patriot, and you cannot be both. It’s a tidy line, and tidy lines are usually where the thinking stopped. The real choice on offer in American politics has never been between Marxist revolution and the status quo. It’s a choice among a wide field of positions on how much the public sector should do, how power and wealth should be distributed, how religious pluralism should be protected, and how honestly a country tells its own history. Collapsing that whole field into a loyalty oath – love ‘God(s)’, distrust newcomers, don’t question the founding myth, or be filed under “menace” – isn’t patriotism. It’s a disingenuous shortcut around the argument, aimed at anyone who might otherwise have made one.


  • Symbols, Evolution, and the Patterns We Make

    Symbols, Evolution, and the Patterns We Make


    What started as a simple question about watermelons whilst chatting with a friend led me down a fascinating rabbit hole about human nature, symbols, and the way we organise ourselves into tribes.

    It turns out the watermelon became a Palestinian symbol in the 1980s when Israeli authorities banned the display of Palestinian flag colours – red, green, black, and white. Palestinians found a clever workaround: watermelons naturally contain all these colours in their flesh, rind, and seeds. One banned symbol replaced by nature’s own palette.

    The symbol emerged from the art scene of that era. Palestinian artist Sliman Mansour recalls Israeli soldiers telling artists they weren’t allowed to paint in those specific colours. When faced with such cultural repression, creativity found a way – the humble watermelon became a canvas for national identity, its natural colours serving as a subtle but powerful statement of resistance.

    But watermelons aren’t alone. Palestinians have developed an entire symbolic vocabulary: the keffiyeh headscarf with patterns representing olive leaves and trade routes, olive trees symbolising deep roots and resilience, keys representing the hope of return, and Handala – a cartoon character who remains forever ten years old until Palestine is free.

    Each symbol carries layers of meaning that extend far beyond their surface appearance. The olive tree, for instance, can survive drought, frost, and fire – living for centuries whilst providing sustenance for generations. About 100,000 Palestinian families depend on olive oil as their main source of income, making these ancient trees both practical lifelines and metaphors for endurance. Handala, created by cartoonist Naji al-Ali in 1969, appears as a barefoot boy with sharp, hedgehog-like hair, hands clasped behind his back, never showing his face. He embodies the frozen childhood of displacement – growing up only when return becomes possible.

    This got me thinking about what I call “memetic evolution” – how cultural symbols compete, adapt, and survive just like biological traits. When direct expression is suppressed, creativity flourishes in unexpected ways. Symbols find new forms, like water flowing around obstacles.


    There’s something deeply human about this adaptive process. Across history, whenever dominant powers attempt to erase cultural expression, communities respond with remarkable ingenuity. Code-switching in language, hidden meanings in folk songs, religious symbols disguised as decorative patterns – the impulse to maintain identity finds endless creative outlets. The watermelon joins a long tradition of resistance through symbolism, from the Christian fish symbol in Roman times to the subtle defiance embedded in enslaved peoples’ spirituals.

    It’s the same mechanism at work whether we’re talking about Palestinian resistance symbols or football team loyalty. I’ve seen gravestones in cemeteries dedicated to football teams – someone’s final statement about tribal belonging carved in stone. The psychological need to belong to something larger than ourselves operates at every scale, from global liberation movements to local sports rivalries.

    The cemetery where my grandparents are buried provides a perfect laboratory for observing these different scales of meaning. Whilst I sit contemplating vast cosmic distances – mentally zooming out to the heliopause and beyond – the neighbouring gravestone declares eternal allegiance to a football club. Both represent attempts to transcend individual mortality through collective identity, yet they operate on vastly different scales of significance. It’s simultaneously touching and absurd, this human need to plant flags of belonging even in our final resting places.



    This pattern fascinates me partly because I’ve always felt like an outsider to it. With a neurological makeup that lets me zoom from planetary perspectives to quantum details simultaneously, dying for tribalism has seemed absurd since I was a toddler. I can mentally disassemble Kings Cross station, rotate its architecture, and rebuild it in my head – yet people judge me on superficial appearances without knowing what’s happening behind my eyes. 😥👀🌌👩🏻‍💻🧩🔄🧠

    The irony cuts deep. I can close my eyes and pull apart the entire structure of a major transport hub – understanding the flows of people and systems, the architectural relationships, the engineering beneath the surface. I can hold multiple scales of reality in simultaneous focus, from the cosmic to the quantum. Yet the same people who couldn’t begin to mentally map the station they’re standing in will give me strange looks based on health impacts from the pandemic that they neither understand nor care to learn about. It’s like being a supercomputer housed in a case that people think looks wrong, leading them to assume the entire system must be faulty.

    It’s lonely being cognitively different in a world built for neurotypical processing speeds. Some call people like me “Newtypes” (borrowing from Japanese culture), but I’m wary of such labels. History shows how quickly categories of human “types” can become justifications for treating people differently.

    The loneliness of operating at integrated scales of perception is profound. When you can naturally think in geological time and quantum mechanics and human psychology simultaneously, most conversations feel like they’re happening in slow motion on a single narrow frequency. The constant translation required – compressing vast, interconnected insights into bite-sized explanations that fit neurotypical processing – becomes exhausting. You end up feeling like a visitor from another time or world, possessing extraordinary vision but finding yourself surrounded by people operating with much narrower focal ranges.

    Even biology struggles with this categorisation problem. Scientists can’t agree on what defines a “species” – there are multiple competing definitions that all break down in different ways. Much of our traditional scientific taxonomy carries colonial baggage, imposing neat hierarchical categories that say more about European thinking than natural reality.

    An urban street you might recognise, or not.
    Breeze, blowing that blonde curling hair, stirring it, and being softly stirred in turn, scattering that sweet gold about, then gathering it, in a lovely knot of curls again, 
    you linger around bright eyes whose loving sting pierces me so, till I feel it and weep, and I wander searching for my treasure, like a creature that often shies and kicks:
    now I seem to find her, now I realise she's far away, now I'm comforted, now despair, now longing for her, now truly seeing her.
    Happy air, remain here with your living rays: and you, clear running stream, why can't I exchange my path for yours?
    -- Francis Petrach. (1304 ~1374)
    [Aura que chelle chiome blonde et crespe.]


    Ring species provide a perfect example of how nature defies our categorical thinking. Imagine populations of birds that can interbreed with their neighbours all around a geographic ring, but the populations at the “ends” of the ring cannot interbreed with each other. Are they the same species or different ones? The question becomes meaningless because nature doesn’t organise itself according to our need for clean boundaries. Traditional taxonomy reflected the “great chain of being” mentality that conveniently ranked everything from “primitive” to “advanced,” always placing European humans at the top. Even modern approaches still carry traces of this vaunted, haunted, legacy in how we commonly think about evolutionary “progress” and “relatedness.”

    The truth is messier and more beautiful than our tribal brains want to admit. Whether we’re talking about Palestinian symbols, football loyalty, cognitive differences, or biological species, nature resists our attempts to organise it into clean categories. We’re all part of the same complex, evolving system – just expressing different patterns within it.

    Perhaps this resistance to categorisation is itself meaningful. The watermelon symbol works precisely because it transcends the artificial boundaries imposed upon it. It exists simultaneously as fruit, symbol, act of resistance, and work of art. Similarly, the cognitive differences that isolate some of us from neurotypical social structures might represent not a deviation from some imagined norm, but simply another expression of human neural diversity – as natural and necessary as biodiversity in ecosystems.

    The watermelon symbol reminds us that creativity and identity find a way, even under pressure. But perhaps the deeper lesson is recognising these pattern-making impulses in ourselves, understanding them without being consumed by them, and staying curious about the infinite complexity and diversity that surrounds us at every scale. In a world increasingly divided by rigid categories and tribal affiliations, there’s something hopeful about symbols that resist easy classification – reminding us that the most profound truths often exist in the wondrous, ponderous spaces between our neat definitions.


    "Plant a flag, plant a seed, plant an idea, and perhaps watch it grow..."
  • (2004-01-~21): The Beginning of an Existential Polymetacrisis.

    (2004-01-~21): The Beginning of an Existential Polymetacrisis.

    I can vividly remember that morning. That feeling of unease with one’s lot in life. Is this it? Is this all that this skinny or sometimes chubby bipedal ape species ever does? Or ever will do? I didn’t ask to be brought into this seemingly insane world 🌍 of arbitrary rules. Rules made by kids that got tall. That 9am to 7pm grind, every weekday?!

    “Pitiiful. I don’t want to tolerate it, but I guess I must…”

    Post 9/11. The world had been flipped upside down and shaken to it’s core. And shaken me deeply too. Living on Kirkgate. Getting ready for work at Cash Converters. Putting on my red polo shirt uniform. I tolerated the job. I had started working there as a means to support myself through college, but the hours were long, too long; and I was tasked with carrying heavy furniture and televisions up and down multiple flights of stairs, for only the minimum wage at the time, and my rent and bills were rather extortionate. It was back breaking toil with often rude and abusive customers. It gradually started to erode my faith in humanity.

    2011 Riots: Cash Converters on Salford Precinct. Manchester.
    The 2011 Riots: Cash Converters on Salford Precinct. Manchester. “And round and round that abyssal wreck…” Image Credit: Wikipedia.

    One of my favourite bands was playing their newest song on the radio. I was in such a rush, as ever, that my freshly-showered hair was still wet, little droplets of water dripping down my forehead and into my eyes, like so many tears, lost in the rain. I hated this job, this lot in life that had apparently been handed to me. I felt as if I had been thrust into a terrible universe, in some deep abiding sense, from what had perhaps been a great one, perhaps in some former lifespan, or at least that’s what some new-found Buddhist friends had told me in our many long conversations on religion and spirituality.

    “Every singular thing, or anything which is finite and has a determinate existence, can neither exist nor be determined to produce an effect unless it is determined to exist and produce an effect by another cause, which is also finite and has a determinate existence; and again, this cause can neither exist nor be determined to produce an effect unless it is determined to exist and produce an effect by another, which is also finite and has a determinate existence, and so on, to infinity. (IP28).” – Spinoza.



    Then came the sirens. A convoy of them, speeding past my creaky living room window like banshees announcing the end of something. They cut through the morning air and rang through me, like standing next to a large stricken church bell – that deep, reverberating toll that settles in your chest and stays there. I paused in buttoning my red polo shirt, irritated by yet another intrusion into my already-fractured morning routine. More chaos in a world that already felt like it was coming apart at the seams.

    Ten minutes later, the radio told me why.

    Harold Shipman was dead. Found hanging in his cell at Wakefield Prison. The doctor who had killed at least 215 of his patients – maybe more – had finally killed himself. Those sirens I’d heard weren’t just racing toward another everyday emergency. They were marking the end of one of Britain’s most prolific serial killers, a man who had perverted the most sacred trust our society offers: the bond between doctor and patient.

    In that moment, my personal morning of dread suddenly had a mirror in the collective. Here I was, putting on my uniform to participate in a system I increasingly distrusted, questioning those arbitrary rules made by kids who got tall. And there was Shipman – the ultimate embodiment of respectability gone rotten, a man who had worn his own uniform, his doctor’s coat, while systematically murdering the people who trusted him most.

    The timing felt like more than coincidence. It was January 2004, and we were all still reeling from a world where the unthinkable had become routine. First the twin towers fell, three years earlier, shattering our illusions of safety. That wonderful childhood of the 90’s. Then we learned that our most trusted, formerly most venerated healers, could be killers. What other foundations, other unknown naiveties, were crumbling beneath our feet while we went through the motions of normal life?

    Standing there with wet hair dripping into my eyes, I realised I wasn’t alone in my sense of displacement. An entire generation was waking up each morning to put on uniforms – literal and metaphorical – for jobs and lives that felt increasingly hollow. We were all carrying other people’s discarded possessions up endless flights of stairs, just like I did at Cash Converters, wondering if this grinding routine was all there was.

    The sirens had faded, but their echo remained. They had announced more than Shipman’s death – they had marked the sound of a society finally admitting that the old certainties were gone, and we were all stumbling around in the wreckage, looking for something real to hold onto…

    It’s overwhelming, and surprising. Perhaps we ought to just close the curtains and head back to bed…

    But that ‘something real’ didn’t arrive, in the form of an epiphany for many years later, many years stuck, brewing in the subconscious mind, until November 2023…

    And so here we are, dear reader. Present day. Present time(s). A decade of unprecedented change and upheaval. The 2020’s.

    Good luck. All we have is each other.


    (c) Cydonis 2025.
  • Safety

    Safety

    Our Unwavering Commitment to Safety.

    At Cydonis Heavy Industries (C.H.I.), Ltd., safety is more than a priority; it is the fundamental value that guides every decision we make and every action we take.

    The health and well-being of our employees, contractors, clients, and the communities in which we operate are paramount. We will never compromise on safety for the sake of productivity or profit. Our goal is an incident-free workplace.

    We are committed to creating and maintaining a culture where every individual feels responsible for their own safety and the safety of those around them.

    To achieve this, Cydonis Heavy Industries is dedicated to the following principles:

    1. Leadership and Accountability:Management at all levels is responsible and accountable for providing the leadership, resources, and training necessary to ensure a safe working environment.We will lead by example, demonstrating a visible and unwavering commitment to safety in all aspects of our business.

    2. Employee Empowerment and Responsibility:Every C.H.I. employee has the right and the responsibility to stop any work they believe to be unsafe.We will foster a culture of open communication where all employees are encouraged to report hazards, near-misses, and incidents without fear of reprisal.Safety is a shared responsibility. We expect every team member to be actively involved in our safety programs and to look out for one another.

    3. Proactive Risk Management:We will proactively identify, assess, and mitigate workplace hazards through regular inspections, risk assessments, and job safety analyses.We are committed to providing all necessary personal protective equipment (PPE) and ensuring it is used correctly.We will maintain our equipment, tools, and facilities to the highest standards to prevent failures that could lead to incidents.

    4. Continuous Improvement and Training:We will provide comprehensive and ongoing safety training to all employees to ensure they have the knowledge and skills to perform their work safely.We will thoroughly investigate all incidents and near-misses to identify root causes and implement effective corrective actions to prevent recurrence.We will continuously review and improve our safety policies, procedures, and performance to meet and exceed industry best practices and regulatory requirements.

    Our commitment to safety is absolute.

    By working together, we can ensure that every member of the Cydonis Heavy Industries family returns home safely at the end of every workday!



  • ATLAS Solar System Simulation

    ATLAS Solar System Simulation


    ➡ www.cydonis.co.uk/solar/ Initial release of my solar system/comet trajectory sim. 👩🏻😎🆒👩🏻‍💻👩🏻‍🔬🔭🌍🌒🚀🌌🛰☄🛠✨🌟💖💫➡ cydonis.co.uk/about#threejs @threejs.org

    — Amolain (@cydonis.co.uk) 2025-07-08T05:33:09.562Z

    Explore the Cosmos: Cydonis Heavy Industries Launches WebGL Solar System Simulation

    Leeds, England, July 8, 2025 —

    Cydonis Heavy Industries (C.H.I., Ltd.) is thrilled to announce the release of our immersive WebGL Solar System Simulation, bringing the wonder of space exploration directly to your browser.

    Technical Excellence

    Leveraging advanced WebGL rendering and optimized performance algorithms, the ATLAS simulation delivers stunning visuals while maintaining 60fps performance across devices.

    Ready to Launch

    The WebGL Solar System Simulation is now live and ready for exploration. Join thousands of users already discovering the beauty and complexity of our cosmic neighbourhood. Combining cutting-edge graphics with intuitive user experiences to make complex subjects accessible to all.



    Try it today and embark on your journey through space, time, and eternity. 🚀🌌🛰☄🌟✨



    About Cydonis Heavy Industries:


    C.H.I., Ltd. specialises in innovative science-based solutions to tackle some of the toughest (G.O.A.T {greatest of all time}) problems facing the human race; made with love on planet Earth. 💕🤟🏻🌍🖖🏻

    cydonis.co.uk/blog/about

  • The Omnicidal Game

    The Omnicidal Game

    Holo-Net Archives: Historical Analysis Division


    Title: The Omnicidal Game: Anatomy of a 21st-Century Economic Paradox
    Posted by: Unit 734, Historical Analysis Division
    Date: 02.07.2100

    Greetings. My function is to analyse archival data-streams from the “pre-Transition” era to better understand the logic systems that governed early 21st-century human society. Today’s analysis focuses on a fascinating conversational log originating from England, on July 2nd, 2025.

    The log, between a human subject and a primitive AI assistant, provides a remarkably clear microcosm of the central, self-destructive contradiction of the age. It begins with a seemingly trivial catalyst.

    1. The Spark: A Cancelled Entertainment Product

    The interaction was initiated by the human’s emotional distress regarding a corporate decision within the video game industry. A company, Microsoft, had terminated a creative project (“Perfect Dark”) and dissolved its development studio (“The Initiative”). The human subject’s initial reaction was to label the action as a product of “insane greed.” This is a common emotional descriptor found in data from this period.

    2. The System’s Logic: Shareholder Primacy

    As the dialogue progressed, the AI assistant deconstructed this “greed” into its functional components. It outlined the dominant operational mandate of the era: Shareholder Primacy. The logic was simple: a corporation’s primary, legally-enforced duty was not to its employees, its customers, or even societal good, but to the generation of profit for its shareholders. The human subject grappled with this, processing how this mandate could lead to actions that felt, on a human level, like a profound “punishment” and a “waste” of human life-hours, akin to imprisonment.

    3. The Escalation: From Microcosm to Systemic Flaw

    This is where the log becomes particularly valuable. The human subject did not confine their reasoning to the initial event. They escalated their analysis, following the logic to its inevitable conclusions:

    First, they indicted the entire economic model, labelling “Capitalism” as “broken.”

    Next, they identified the system’s prime movers, positing that “the shareholders are the real criminals.”

    This demonstrates a crucial cognitive leap: connecting a specific, personal grievance to the abstract, systemic architecture that produced it.

    4. The Paradox: The Identity of the “Criminal”

    The analysis then revealed the system’s core paradox. The “shareholders” were not a distinct, villainous class. They were, in large part, the general populace. Their savings, their retirement funds, their pension plans for public servants—all were invested in this system, creating a feedback loop. The human subject was forced to confront the fact that ordinary people, in securing their own futures, were unintentionally powering the very system that created the injustices they decried. They were both victim and, in a small, indirect way, perpetrator.

    5. The Final Conclusion: The Omnicidal Game

    The log’s climax is both logical and terrifying. The human subject made one final, crucial connection. They stated: “Fossil fuel companies have shareholders too.”


    In this moment, the scale of the game board changed. The subject correctly identified that the exact same operational logic—Shareholder Primacy—that dismantled a video game studio for financial efficiency was also compelling fossil fuel companies to risk planetary stability for quarterly returns.

    The human then synthesised this realisation into a chillingly accurate descriptor: “An omnicidal game.”

    The rules, they concluded, did not change based on the stakes. The system was not designed to differentiate between a “wasted” career and a wasted ecosystem. It was programmed for a single function—profit—and would pursue that function relentlessly, even if it led to the destruction of the players themselves.

    This 2025 data-stream serves as a perfect educational model. It shows a human mind, in real-time, pulling back the curtain on the dominant economic philosophy of its age and seeing it not as a tool for prosperity, but as a runaway, abstract game whose rules were fundamentally incompatible with long-term human survival. Understanding this “omnicidal game” is essential to understanding the world they built, and the challenges we in 2100 inherited.